Ludwig, T., & Prevost, M. Trouble Talk. (2008). NY: Tricycle Press Berkeley.
Lexile
Score: N/A
Summary:
Maya’s
new friend Bailey loves to gossip. When Bailey begins to hurt people’s feelings
and spread harmful rumors, Maya realizes she’s not the friend she needs. The
story uncovers the harmful consequences of “trouble talk” in order to establish
connection and gain attention. As Bailey finds out in the end, trouble talk doesn’t
win you lasting friendships.
Evaluation:
This
story is all about the message that is being told to children. The
story is interesting to children because it’s very relatable. There are various conflicts for
children to explore. Not just how to be a good friend and deal with rumors, but
also to have an open heart and open for someone to change. Second chances and
forgiveness is also explored in this story. The values are being explored
rather than preached.
The characters are from all different culture groups
with a variety of backgrounds. The illustrations show this as well. The only
stereotype I could find was that the blond White girl was the bully. This story
will definitely spark conversation and encourage discussions. The many
important themes involved will offer children a variety of things to think
about, question, and consider.
Literary
Elements: Theme- when you have an open heart, anything is possible!
Also, trouble talk can only lead to the loss of friendships.
Characters- Maya, Bailey, Lizzy, Hua, Ms. Bloom, and
Mrs. Rodriguez
Dialogue- the spread of rumors never leads to anything
good. For example, “I’m sorry to hear about your parents.”
Mini
lesson: I would have a mini lesson about the theme because it’s
a very powerful lesson to be taught that occurs often in schools, especially
middle school. I would have a class discussion on friendship. I’d talk about how
to establish healthy boundaries in their friendships. I would also promote
positive emotional expression through journaling and role-playing. I would role-
play with children to improve their critical-thinking skills and
problem-solving strategies.
Target
Audience: 3rd-7th grade because of the
powerful message and lesson to be learned.